 |
  |
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
invizion Rapscallion
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
|
Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 3:37 pm Post subject: Weekly Update - UFO Edition |
|
|
Hi guys and welcome to another weekly update!
Its been an interesting week in TVL, from drama to the just damn funny.
Last week I mentioned a EP Reward for members that help to recruit new and compentent raiders, This is STILL running, please ask whoever you get to apply to also put that YOU have sent them there to apply, if they complete their trial you will be awared with 1000 EP for nothing!
One thing I feel needs to be said is that quite a few people dont understand how the EPGP system works. It does NOT work like DKP.... it works on a priority system. So for example if you start hoarding EP, your EP decay will be drastic to the point of you will be coming to raids and earning no extra EP in a raiding week as you will lose just as much in the weekly decay. If you want a piece of armour... roll for it, dont wait for the OMG BiS epix... you will get it eventually.... you are just gimping both yourself and the rest of the raid. If people continue to play the system like this, we may have to look at punishing via -EP for those select few.
Last week we saw an argument in guild chat between Tarah and Wrwf which caused Braincracker to leave the guild?! Not entirely sure how that works, however we all wish him the best of luck with whatever he decides to do.
We've seen some new faces also around the guild by the names of -
Bloodypengu
Cowness
Deadlycatch
Novatrix
Soulcraft
And last but not least, Cobblepot (aka Kartha) who has been accepted for a trial after being a community member. So on behalf of the Officer team, Welcome to the guild!
We also said welcome and goodbye to Inot who seems to of been upducted by aliens ? AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
So... now thats out of the way... raiding news ;D
RG1 - These guys have appeared to of caught up with RG2 on the boss kill side of progression, they are trying to perfect phase 2 of the Lich King fight. Congrats to them, the race for the first "King slayer" is now on!
RG2 - Not an awful lot of progress from what Ive been told, still having problems with regulars away on holiday, however supposedly back to full strenth for next week, good luck guys!
RG3 - Every week I get surprised by these guys, OK they're not the fastest progessing group, however, Festergut was 1shot, after weeks of wipes to 1 shotting every week, these guys are going from stregnth to stregnth, Rotface was also killed after 1 wipe. This was our first attempt at Rotface and I can safely say, that im highly impressed with how well everything seems to be coming together (at last). Just a reminder to RG3 members, we now run on a Monday and Tuesday evening due to the change in the 25 man raid days, please sign up for these days on your ingame calender.
25 Man - Putricide is FINALLY down. need I say more?
Just a note to the 25 man raiders, 25 man days are now Wednesday, Thursdays and Sundays. Again please sign up via the ingame calender for any raids you can attend, the more the better!
Since no questions have been asked this week, theres nothing I can answer if you do have any questions just leave a reply on this thread, send me a private message on the forums or email me at dale.wall40(nospampl0x)ntlworld.com with the subject Weekly Update question.
On a Final note, I ask all raiders to install EPGP Lootmaster, This will bring up a UI interface when loot is distributed(similar to the group loot UI in dungeons), makes the Master Looters life easier as they will know if you are interested and wether its for OS or MS.
So untill next week.... I must dash as the aliens have arrived.... AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH |
|
| Back to top |
|
nia Window Licker
Joined: 24 Oct 2006
|
Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 6:17 pm Post subject: Re: Weekly Update - UFO Edition |
|
|
| invizion wrote: | | One thing I feel needs to be said is that quite a few people dont understand how the EPGP system works. It does NOT work like DKP.... it works on a priority system. So for example if you start hoarding EP, your EP decay will be drastic to the point of you will be coming to raids and earning no extra EP in a raiding week as you will lose just as much in the weekly decay. If you want a piece of armour... roll for it, dont wait for the OMG BiS epix... you will get it eventually.... you are just gimping both yourself and the rest of the raid. If people continue to play the system like this, we may have to look at punishing via -EP for those select few. |
strongly disagree with this, sure stating interest in items that are good for you instead of waiting for the super duper BIS, say like trinkets, vs normal gear that people save up for, i understand the thought here, the trinkets going to be amazing in everyones hands, but you worry people are intentionally gimping themselves by saving to get it first, trying to prevent that is good enough, but this idea just seems to encourage people to "bid" on sub par items (to use everyones favourite example, spirit shamans! ) which actually does hurt the raids gear level as a whole unless no one else wanted said item, which isn't likely in icc. but maybe thats more something officers need to decide on. What classes can take what (to use an example the restriction on cloth to druids should apply to stats like spirit to shamans, it's far more important even since armour class actually changes nothing, while those stats do).
Grats on the chance to raid again tom, keep up to date on class changes and how to maximize dps and you should do fine, after years playing alongside you in the mage team i trust you to get the other aspects of fights no problem
sad to hear about braincracker, played with him some in rg2 where he was more vocal, and him leaving is a sad loss for the guild, as a skilled player who also always seemed to want what was best for the raids overall success, good luck in whatever you go on to do.
and finally, grats on the progress, by looks of it putri is the second hardest boss in there, so hopefully you can repeat this kill and score a few more quickly, also good job rg3, i was worried that with me gone the healing setup might again become less than ideal(paladins=win.), but it's encouraging to hear you 1 shotted festergut again.
hmmz, questions; what were tahra and wrwf arguing about this time? and has there been any discussion on more officer control on loot distribution and rules etc in the super secret /o, or do you still support dkp is king (now edgp) as i felt this was causing arguments a few weeks back |
|
| Back to top |
|
Blackxdeath Hi i've posted 2500 times

Joined: 23 Oct 2006 Location: Norway
|
Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 9:20 pm Post subject: |
|
|
well when it comes to the EPGP system, u have 3 stats, EP, GP and PR. now PR is the stat that is important because it desides your priority on loot. the PR stat is calculated from your EP (what u earn from raiding etc, this is a stat that will only increase and "never" decrease) devided by your GP (u start with 100 and has a amount added to it equel to the value of a item each time u buy said item)
so when i had about 60k EP and 100 GP i had about 600 PR, then i picked up a neck that cost like 275 and i was then at 375 GP and my PR was reduced from 600 to 160ish.
thing is that i understand that ppl that bhav skip bidding on stuff like the weapon from putri even if its a huge upgrade to save for the item u realy want... if my neck had cost more (like 400) i would never have bought it, since i knew i would still be on top of tanks however, i bid and got it. i also didnt bid on the tier token since it would get me below kalas and maybe even invizion/bigyin....
this is how u have to play the EPGP system if u want the best upgrades, if u officers thoght it would play out any other way u where damn naive...
as for the decay, everybody get the same decay (sure it makes a bigger dent into the EP of ppl with loads of it, but it should make the same dent into PR for everybody... placement vise atleast), and i had to lol when i read "if you start hoarding EP"... u cant lose EP(noticble amounts atleast, not counting the decay, but again that effects everybody).... only gain GP wich inturn will reduce PR. and even if u lose EP equal to the cost of the items u buy (u might allready do this, i dont know and would not have noticed if u do)... the items are dirt cheap when it comes to EP but effects the PR loads... in progress raids we get more EP every 15 min then a normal item costs to buy....
sure passing on a realy good upgrade like bhav did might seem a little stupid. but i expect loads of gear to ether be DEd, go to off specs (which get it for free) or loads of gear going to fresh ppl like naddar that allready are at the bottom of PR. ppl that that are high up on the PR list and allready have good gear will refrain to bid on small upgrades since it effects there PR to mutch...
the EPGP system works best if u start using it with a "fresh start" like a new expansion and with a steady raid group... currently the fact that PR=EP/GP means that buying items will effect your PR to mutch since buing a weapon for 550 when u only have 100 GP will reduce your PR to about 15% of what it used to be. a good example was last raid when the dagger got sharded, since no rogue was dagger speced they chose to let it be DEed instead of taking it for min bid incase they wanted to go dagger down the line since they knew it would fuck over there PR for months to come...
the fact that if i (or any of the other tanks) chose to go for the tank belt that droped from festergot for a sidgrade avoidance set instead of giving it to a dps that allready had so low PR that he had nothing to lose happend sorta proved the flaw of the system for items that are side grades or your the only one that needs...
both me, kalas and invizion have the badge belt, but im sure we all wanted it for a side grade avoidance set. but taking it would mean sutch a big bite into our PR that it would feel like we had just been raped by the entire troll nation....
another good example is the tanking bracers from first boss, as far as i know im the only tank that dont have em (since i desided to pass em to the other tanks under the old loot system, since they needed the upgrade more then me), now i will not bid for it until i have the lowest PR of all the tanks since its a small upgrade...
now u talk about abusing the system, an "whats good for the raid/guild", THIS IS how this system works and how its been "played" by all who use it, just read some forum posts about it...
its ALL about your PR standing compared to the ppl u compete with for your section of the loot pool, be it tank, healer or dps. ppl WILL save for that one item they feel is there biggest upgrade. the ppl that benefit from it are the ppl that are on the bottom of the PR list and has nothing to lose.
sure it will even out in cataclysm but for Wrath it will be like it is since many ppl need so few upgrades. and its gona be worse when RG1 and 2 gets down LK and start doing hard modes that give em better (same item lvl, but better itemized) loot then what u get in 25 man normal.
im sure that ppl would buy more items if the initila EP was bigger or item costs was smaller, since it just takes to big a chunk out of your PR as is. sure when all raid members have used this system for like 10+ items the buying of a new item isnt gona bump u from top 5 PR to bottom 5 PR like its now...
sorry for the WoT, but it had to be said.
PS. nice work on the weekly update once again, and good job with the second putri kill, maybe next time we dont need 6-7 trys and 15 ppl dead when he dies^^
now lets get that bloody queen (no pun intended) on sunday and maybe even sleepy dragon to \o/
EDIT: LOOOL think my post turned out bigger then the weekly update  _________________ World of Warcraft + Manowar = Godlyness
Makes u want to play more WoW^^
There is hope for Blizzard yet!! |
|
| Back to top |
|
invizion Rapscallion
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
|
Posted: Fri Feb 26, 2010 9:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
bxd, im not playing the system atall, if an upgrade drops or avoidance side set piece drops, ill roll on it, simples.... at the end of the day i may have a low pr rating but ill sure as hell be more versatile when it comes to certain encounters and will be better prepared... at the end of the day, every raider needs to make a choice... either go for the greed route or go for gearing to the best they can....
taking the greed route means really u shouldnt be raiding but u should be pugging as ur in it for urself no1 else...... if you take the versatility route your helping yourself aswell as the guild... |
|
| Back to top |
|
Grimtharr Bored at Work

Joined: 23 Oct 2006 Location: The Tower
|
Posted: Sat Feb 27, 2010 3:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | thing is that i understand that ppl that bhav skip bidding on stuff like the weapon from putri even if its a huge upgrade to save for the item u realy want... |
| Quote: |
another good example is the tanking bracers from first boss, as far as i know im the only tank that dont have em (since i desided to pass em to the other tanks under the old loot system, since they needed the upgrade more then me), now i will not bid for it until i have the lowest PR of all the tanks since its a small upgrade... |
Small upgrade? - No thanks. Huge upgrade? No thanks.
I read throught the insanely hard to read reply by bxd, but still can't see what the deal is. It seems to me that you are only afraid of not being "on top" of the priolist and getting a piece before any other snags it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
Bigyin WoW Guild Master

Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Location: England
|
Posted: Sat Feb 27, 2010 4:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Indeed the new system encourages two things
1)Going for items as soon as they are available to you.
2)Keeping an active attendance.
If you hold out for a BIS item, you are welcome to do so, but it will only mean after taking that item you go to the bottom, or at least lower priority. Thats the whole point of the system.
It prevents any kind of 'DKP' hording, and encourages people to quickly get any upgrade item. _________________ Just enough education to Tank.
BxD's words of wisdom, A Druids Motto
You're a Druid... you are expected to have the lowest overhealing (by far) and the most healed (by far), you are also expected to die more....
You are also expected to give Subliment innervate when needed (that is if he is not dead), you are also expected start a CR chain where you ress a Druid, that resses a Druid, that resses a Druid. Then that Druid resses Subliment... |
|
| Back to top |
|
Blackxdeath Hi i've posted 2500 times

Joined: 23 Oct 2006 Location: Norway
|
Posted: Sat Feb 27, 2010 6:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
yes bigyin, but. and this is a BIG but. for this system to work like its ment to u need 2 things : 1. a steady raid group and 2. a equal starting out point regarding gear. the second point will fix it self over time, the first isnt.
and tbh invision...
| Quote: | | taking the greed route means really u shouldnt be raiding but u should be pugging as ur in it for urself no1 else...... if you take the versatility route your helping yourself aswell as the guild... |
i didnt see you bidding on the belt... and its a better side grade for you then me or kalas...
and are u kidding me? WTH should anybody use there PR for "versatility" over there main job. sure if its free, but not if u need to pay in blood.
u call it greed route, i call it ensuring that my char gets the best gear for the job im expected to perform. if that means passing on a small upgrade so i have shot at at a bigger/better upgrade then so be it....
this will happen to everybody.. fixed price systems are bound to fail, because some items are better then others and thus worth more, also the value of a item depends on whos in the raid and what lvl of progress one is at. in the few raids we have done with this system we have seen it several times allready.... the only once that benefit are new ppl with nothing to lose and ppl gearing offspechs. tanks/healers will not take sidegrades that MIGHT be usefull down the line since they cost to mutch and dps will not take gear that dont direcly benifits them then and there or in a short time span. like the dagger that got DEd. loads of plate dps gear will end up on tanks since its free for OS, since the warrior/DK/pally are currently capped with the stat that it provides and cba to get bumped to bottom of the PR for his bracket...
invision, what u said about about saving for BiS item is greedy, that total BS, the way u get to be best in dps in a equal skill enviroment is to have the best balanced gear for your job.
we have allways been talking about "planing your gear" in the every thread i can think of when it comes to maximising your caracter for its intended job... what u are saying is that we should bid on the first and best upgrade that comes along, even if it cost us a major ugrade later, sorry mack thats not how i play and it never will. _________________ World of Warcraft + Manowar = Godlyness
Makes u want to play more WoW^^
There is hope for Blizzard yet!! |
|
| Back to top |
|
Bigyin WoW Guild Master

Joined: 22 Oct 2006 Location: England
|
Posted: Sat Feb 27, 2010 6:55 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I think its fair to say you wont be happy with the system so I dont see the point in pointing out its merits. Suffice to say though the system is working for the grander scheme of raiding. _________________ Just enough education to Tank.
BxD's words of wisdom, A Druids Motto
You're a Druid... you are expected to have the lowest overhealing (by far) and the most healed (by far), you are also expected to die more....
You are also expected to give Subliment innervate when needed (that is if he is not dead), you are also expected start a CR chain where you ress a Druid, that resses a Druid, that resses a Druid. Then that Druid resses Subliment... |
|
| Back to top |
|
invizion Rapscallion
Joined: 11 Sep 2009
|
Posted: Sun Feb 28, 2010 1:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | i didnt see you bidding on the belt... and its a better side grade for you then me or kalas...
|
I wasnt present at that raid afaik, if i was i would of bid on it to form part of my avoidance set |
|
| Back to top |
|
Herbs VG Knight
Joined: 23 Oct 2006
|
Posted: Mon Mar 15, 2010 5:22 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Feck it Ninja Roll Free for ALL !
Herbs (firestarter) |
|
| Back to top |
|
|
|
  |
|
All times are GMT |
| Page 1 of 1 |
|
 |
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|